Menu
Welcome to Benny's Pizza, where you can enjoy a wide variety of menu options, including salads, appetizers, wings, and of course, delicious pizzas. Located at 968 Columbus Ave Marysville, OH 43040, Benny's Pizza offers services like takeout, reservations, delivery, and outdoor seating. The restaurant is known for its many vegetarian options, accommodating for all dietary preferences.
Customers rave about the amazing pizza and wings, as well as the live music and vibrant atmosphere at Benny's Pizza. Reviews highlight the great service, filling portions, and enjoyable dining experience. Whether you're in the mood for a flavorful salad or a satisfying pizza, Benny's Pizza has something for everyone. Don't miss out on this popular spot for a fun night out with friends or family.
Saint Patrick's Week

Reuben on Rye
Tender corned beef, swiss cheese and sauerkraut on toasted rye with a side of thousand island
Reuben Dip
This creamy dip is made with deli fresh corned beef, cream cheese, sauerkraut and Swiss cheese. Served with toasted rye, tortilla chips and thousand island dressing on the side
Shepherd's Pie Pizza - Personal
While supplies last each day! Our famous pizza crust covered with ground beef, carrots, peas, onions and tomatoes in a worcestershire based sauce, then topped with provolone cheese and mashed potatoes and baked to perfection. See our website for more St Patty's favorites that are only available in the dining room this week!
Shepherd's Pie Pizza - Small
While supplies last each day! Our famous pizza crust covered with ground beef, carrots, peas, onions and tomatoes in a worcestershire based sauce, then topped with provolone cheese and mashed potatoes and baked to perfection. See our website for more St Patty's favorites that are only available in the dining room this week!
Shepherd's Pie Pizza - Medium
While supplies last each day! Our famous pizza crust covered with ground beef, carrots, peas, onions and tomatoes in a worcestershire based sauce, then topped with provolone cheese and mashed potatoes and baked to perfection. See our website for more St Patty's favorites that are only available in the dining room this week!
Shepherd's Pie Pizza - Large
While supplies last each day! Our famous pizza crust covered with ground beef, carrots, peas, onions and tomatoes in a worcestershire based sauce, then topped with provolone cheese and mashed potatoes and baked to perfection. See our website for more St Patty's favorites that are only available in the dining room this week!
Large House Salad
Iceberg and Romaine lettuce topped with Provolone cheese, tomatoes, red onions, croutons and your choice of dressing (2 packets).
Small House Salad
Iceberg and Romaine lettuce topped with Provolone cheese, tomatoes, red onions, croutons and your choice of dressing.
Large Chef Salad
Iceberg and Romaine topped with Swiss, Cheddar and Provolone cheese, turkey, ham, red onion, green peppers, tomatoes, egg wedges, croutons and your choice of dressing (2 packets).
Small Chef Salad
Iceberg and Romaine topped with Swiss, Cheddar and Provolone cheese, turkey, ham, red onion, green peppers, tomatoes, egg wedges, croutons and your choice of dressing.
Large Anitpasto Salad
Iceberg and Romaine lettuce topped with salami, ham, capicola ham, Provolone cheese, fresh mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes, red onions and your choice of dressing (2 packets).
Small Antipasto Salad
Iceberg and Romaine lettuce topped with salami, ham, capicola ham, Provolone cheese, fresh mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes, red onions and your choice of dressing.
BBQ Chicken Cobb Salad
Iceberg and Romaine lettuce, smoked BBQ chicken, Cheddar and Provolone cheese, bacon, diced eggs, tomatoes, red onions, roasted corn and your choice of dressing (2 packets).
Honey Mustard Chicken Salad
Tender smoked chicken breast tossed in honey mustard sauce on a bed of iceberg and Romaine lettuce with bacon, Cheddar and Provolone cheese, tomatoes, red onions, chives, pita bread wedges and your choice of dressing.
Salads

Appetizers & Wings

Smoked Bone-In Wings
Our delicious smoked bone-in wings are hickory smoked on-side daily! We bake them to order are toss them in your favorite sauce.
Boneless Wings - Full 1 lb.
Delicious boneless chicken wings tossed in your choice of our wing sauce
Boneless Wings - 1/2 lb.
Delicious boneless chicken wings tossed in your choice of our wing sauce
Garlic Bread with Cheese - 8 Piece
Delicious garlic bread with cheese served with a side of hot marinara sauce.
Garlic Bread with Cheese - 4 Piece
Delicious garlic bread with cheese served with a side of hot marinara sauce.
Baked Spinach Dip
Our homemade creamy baked spinach dip topped with Provolone, Feta and Parmesan cheese. Served with tortilla chips, pita bread wedges and crackers.
Braided Pretzel Twists
Two warm, soft baked braided pretzel twists served with your choice of beer cheese or cream cheese. Mustard by request
LeeLee's Buffalo Chicken Dip
Homemade Buffalo chicken dip topped with cheddar & provolone cheese. Served with tortilla chips, celery sticks and blue cheese dressing on the side.
Chicken Tenders
Five chicken tenders served with BBQ sauce or your choice of dressing.
Crab Smothered Mushrooms
Fresh jumbo mushrooms caps smothered in our creamy crabmeat recipe. Topped with Provolone and Parmesan cheese and baked to perfection.
Pizza Skins
A personal pizza crust topped with potatoes, cheddar & provolone cheese, bacon, red onion, chives, and a side of sour cream
Italian Sub
A sub bun loaded with pepperoni, ham, salami, Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, banana peppers and Italian dressing.
Super Sub
An Italian sub with mushrooms.
Ham & Cheese Sub
A sub bun stacked with our premium smoked applewood ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and a side of mayo.
Turkey Sub
A sub bun stuffed with deli sliced turkey, Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise on the side.
Club Sub
Turkey, bacon, ham and swiss cheese toasted on our delicious sub bun. Then topped with lettuce, tomatoes and mayonnaise.
Veggie Sub
A sub bun filled with mushrooms, Provolone cheese, green peppers, black olives, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, banana peppers and Italian dressing.
Pizza Sub
A sub bun filled with Benny's famous pizza sauce, Provolone cheese and one of your favorite pizza toppings
Meatball Sub
A sub bun stuffed with meatballs, marinara sauce and Provolone cheese.
Gyro
Pita bread stuffed with beef and lamb,feta, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and homemade cucumber sauce. Served with a side of chips
Buffalo Chicken Sub
Two breaded chicken patties tossed in Buffalo sauce and loaded onto a toasted Italian sub bun with provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and a side of ranch
Chicken Parmesan Sub
Two breaded chicken patties topped with provolone & parmesan cheese and loaded onto a toasted Italian sub bun with marinara sauce
Brisket Sub
Our signature beef brisket sauteed in your choice of Au Jus, Robin's BBQ or Chipotle BBQ. Served on a toasted sub bun with provolone cheese
Sweet Chili Chicken Wrap
Grilled chicken, onions, green peppers and sweet chili sauce loaded into a flour tortilla with melted cheddar & provolone cheese and lettuce
Chicken Salad Sub
Our delicious house-made chicken salad with melted provolone cheese, lettuce and tomato
Subs and Sandwiches

Pizza

14" Large Pizza
Our signature crust & pizza sauce, topped with freshly shredded provolone cheese and your choice of toppings.
12" Medium Pizza
Our signature crust & pizza sauce, topped with freshly shredded provolone cheese and your choice of toppings.
10" Small Pizza
Our signature crust & pizza sauce, topped with freshly shredded provolone cheese and your choice of toppings. Gluten Free crust is available for our 10" pizzas upon request. Our pizza sauce is gluten free, but our BBQ sauces do contain gluten. If you have an allergy and would like us to use gloves, foil, and leave your pizza uncut, please let us know in the "Special Instructions" section. Otherwise, we will make it and cut it like normal. Thanks! =)
7" Personal Pizza
Our signature crust & pizza sauce, topped with freshly shredded provolone cheese and your choice of toppings.
Personal 5 Meat Pizza
Marinara sauce, spicy smoked sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, capicola ham, Italian sausage and Provolone cheese.
Personal BBQ Chicken Pizza
Robin's BBQ sauce, smoked chicken, Provolone and Cheddar cheese, bacon and red onions.
Personal All the Way Pizza
Pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushroom, onions, green peppers, banana peppers and Provolone cheese.
Personal Greek Pizza
Garlic olive oil, Provolone and Feta cheese, spinach, black olives, tomatoes and red onions.
Personal Veggie Pizza
Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, banana peppers, tomatoes and Provolone cheese.
Personal BLT Pizza
Bacon, Provolone and Cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and mayonnaise.
Personal Hawaiian Pizza
Ham, pineapple, green peppers, onions and Provolone cheese.
Personal Gyro Pizza
Our famous pizza crust topped with your choice of lamb and beef or oven roasted chicken, cucumber sauce, provolone cheese, feta cheese, spinach, tomato, and red onions.
Personal Chicken Ranchero Pizza
Oven roasted chicken breast, bacon, creamy ranch dressing, red onion and tomato.
Specialty Pizzas - Personal

Specialty Pizzas - Medium

Medium 5 Meat Pizza
Marinara sauce, spicy smoked sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, capicola ham, Italian sausage and Provolone cheese.
Medium BBQ Chicken Pizza
Robin's BBQ sauce, smoked chicken, Provolone and Cheddar cheese, bacon and red onions.
Medium All the Way Pizza
Pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushroom, onions, green peppers, banana peppers and Provolone cheese.
Medium Greek Pizza
Garlic olive oil, Provolone and Feta cheese, spinach, black olives, tomatoes and red onions.
Medium Veggie Pizza
Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, banana peppers, tomatoes and Provolone cheese.
Medium BLT Pizza
Bacon, Provolone and Cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and mayonnaise.
Medium Hawaiian Pizza
Ham, pineapple, green peppers, onions and Provolone cheese.
Medium Garbage Pizza
Pepperoni, Italian sausage, spicy smoked sausage, onions, mushrooms, green peppers, ham, tomatoes, black olives, green olives, bacon, pineapple, banana peppers, jalepeno peppers and Provolone cheese. Anchovies by request only.
Medium Gyro Pizza
Our famous pizza crust topped with your choice of lamb and beef or oven roasted chicken, cucumber sauce, provolone cheese, feta cheese, spinach, tomato, and red onions.
Medium Chicken Ranchero Pizza
Oven roasted chicken breast, bacon, creamy ranch dressing, red onion and tomato.
Medium Southwest Brisket Pizza
This pizza starts with a chipotle BBQ sauce and is topped with our signature smoked brisket, cheddar and provolone cheese, spicy smoked sausage, red pepper, green pepper, red onion and banana peppers.
Small Garbage Pizza
Pepperoni, Italian sausage, spicy smoked sausage, onions, mushrooms, green peppers, ham, tomatoes, black olives, green olives, bacon, pineapple, banana peppers, jalepeno peppers and Provolone cheese. Anchovies by request only.
Small 5 Meat Pizza
Marinara sauce, spicy smoked sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, capicola ham, Italian sausage and Provolone cheese.
Small All the Way Pizza
Pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushroom, onions, green peppers, banana peppers and Provolone cheese.
Small BBQ Chicken Pizza
Robin's BBQ sauce, smoked chicken, Provolone and Cheddar cheese, bacon and red onions.
Small Greek Pizza
Garlic olive oil, Provolone and Feta cheese, spinach, black olives, tomatoes and red onions.
Small Veggie Pizza
Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, banana peppers, tomatoes and Provolone cheese.
Small BLT Pizza
Bacon, Provolone and Cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and mayonnaise.
Small Hawaiian Pizza
Ham, pineapple, green peppers, onions and Provolone cheese.
Small Gyro Pizza
Our famous pizza crust topped with your choice of lamb and beef or oven roasted chicken, cucumber sauce, provolone cheese, feta cheese, spinach, tomato, and red onions.
Small Chicken Ranchero Pizza
Oven roasted chicken breast, bacon, creamy ranch dressing, red onion and tomato.
Small Southwest Brisket Pizza
This pizza starts with a chipotle BBQ sauce and is topped with our signature smoked brisket, cheddar and provolone cheese, spicy smoked sausage, red pepper, green pepper, red onion and banana peppers.
Specialty Pizzas - Small

Specialty Pizzas - Large

Large 5 Meat Pizza
Pizza Sauce, spicy smoked sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, capicola ham, Italian sausage and Provolone cheese.
Large BBQ Chicken Pizza
Robin's BBQ sauce, smoked chicken, Provolone and Cheddar cheese, bacon and red onions.
Large All the Way Pizza
Pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushroom, onions, green peppers, banana peppers and Provolone cheese.
Large Greek Pizza
Garlic olive oil, Provolone and Feta cheese, spinach, black olives, tomatoes and red onions.
Large Veggie Pizza
Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, banana peppers, tomatoes and Provolone cheese.
Large BLT Pizza
Bacon, Provolone and Cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and mayonnaise.
Large Hawaiian Pizza
Ham, pineapple, green peppers, onions and Provolone cheese.
Large Garbage Pizza
Pepperoni, Italian sausage, spicy smoked sausage, onions, mushrooms, green peppers, ham, tomatoes, black olives, green olives, bacon, pineapple, banana peppers, jalepeno peppers and Provolone cheese. Anchovies by request only.
Large Gyro Pizza
Our famous pizza crust topped with your choice of lamb and beef or oven roasted chicken, cucumber sauce, provolone cheese, feta cheese, spinach, tomato, and red onions.
Large Chicken Ranchero Pizza
Oven roasted chicken breast, bacon, creamy ranch dressing, red onion and tomato.
Large Southwest Brisket Pizza
This pizza starts with a chipotle BBQ sauce and is topped with our signature smoked brisket, cheddar and provolone cheese, spicy smoked sausage, red pepper, green pepper, red onion and banana peppers.
Pizza Bowl
Crust-free pizza! It's a personal pizza made in a tin instead of on crust.
Italian Foldover
A delicious pizza crust stuffed with ham, salami, pepperoni and Provolone cheese. Once baked to perfection, we open it up and add lettuce, tomatoes, hot peppers, red onions and Italian dressing. Pizza sauce on the side.
Traditional Stromboli
Your favorite pizza topping rolled into our famous dough with Provolone cheese. Served with a side of pizza sauce.
Bolis, Bowls, and Folds

Signature Entrees

Robin's BBQ Ribs - Full Rack 14
Perfectly seasoned, hickory smoked ribs. Half and full racks served with a side of Texas toast.
Robin's BBQ Ribs - Half Rack 7
Perfectly seasoned, hickory smoked ribs. Half and full racks served with a side of Texas toast.
Robin's BBQ Ribs - Rib Appeteaser 4
Perfectly seasoned, hickory smoked ribs. Half and full racks served with a side of Texas toast.
Garlic Dipping Sauce
Ranch Packet
Side of Pizza Sauce
Side of Banana Peppers
Side of Frank's/Buffalo
Side of Robin's BBQ
Side of Beer Cheese
Side of Chipotle BBQ
Side of Cucumber Sauce - 2oz
Side of Cucumber Sauce - 4oz
Side of Jalapenos
Side of Spicy Garlic
Side of Sour Cream
Celery
Side of celery.
Side Items

Side Dishes

Beer-Battered Fries
Homemade Cole Slaw
2-Liter of Pop
You can select what you like when you come in. We stock 2-liter bottles of Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Diet Mountain Dew, Sierra Mist, and Mug Root Beer.
20oz Pop or Water - 1 Bottle
You can select what you like when you come in. We stock Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Dr Pepper, and Mug Root Beer.
20oz Pop or Water - 4 Bottles
You can select what you like when you come in. We stock Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Dr Pepper, and Mug Root Beer.
Cup of Homemade Root Beer
A 21 cup of our Homemade Root Beer. Ice only by request.
Gallon of Homemade Root Beer (Bring a container )
An entire gallon of our homemade root beer. ***You must provide an empty gallon container when you come to pick it up!***
20oz Water
20oz Aquafina
Pop

Desserts

Eli's Cheesecake Original
One Slice of Eli's Cheesecake: Original Cheesecake Flavor
Eli's Cheesecake Strawberry Swirl
One Slice of Eli's Cheesecake: Strawberry Swirl Flavor
Eli's Cheesecake Chocolate Chip
One Slice of Eli's Cheesecake: Chocolate Chip Flavor
Buckeye Pie
Take home a slice of O H - I O! Dark Chocolate & Peanut Butter Mousse, topped with Reese's Peanut Butter Cups.
$25 Gift Certificate
Gift certificates can be redeemed by calling in your carryout order, or they can be used in the dining room. They can be purchased for curbside pickup here, but cannot be redeemed for online orders - only called in orders... we're still old fashioned ;-)
$10 Gift Certificate
Gift certificates can be redeemed by calling in your carryout order, or they can be used in the dining room. They can be purchased for curbside pickup here, but cannot be redeemed for online orders - only called in orders... we're still old fashioned ;-)
$5 Gift Certificate
Gift certificates can be redeemed by calling in your carryout order, or they can be used in the dining room. They can be purchased for curbside pickup here, but cannot be redeemed for online orders - only called in orders... we're still old fashioned ;-)
Buy Gift Certificates
